In the fall of 1885, an organization was begun in Dayton. For some time they met in a little dingy hall on Main Street known as Kulin's Hall. It was an upper floor of a downtown store. Brother S. Hamilton, of Dixie, occasionally preached for them. Early in 1886, J. B. Daisley, an energetic little Scotsman of LeRoy, Pennsylvania, began a series of meetings which culminated in the organization of the First Christian Church of Dayton on February 7, 1886. There were 40 charter members.
The Daisley meetings exceeded all expectations and on March 19 there were a total of 123 members in the church. At that time,the Baileysburg church merged with the Dayton congregation and swelled the membership to 185.